Thrift Store Tray Makeover

October 8, 2019

Grab an old tray at the thrift store and a stencil that makes you smile and you can have a fabulous and affordable year round decor accessory in no time flat.

Bargain Tray Makeover

Last week I shared a stencil craft fail. Look, it happens. When you craft as much as I do, you're bound to run into the occasional bump in the road.

The general consensus was live and learn and I totally agree.

Thankfully, I'm a pretty quick learner and I put my new knowledge to work right away.

I was in the middle of an unstoppable crafting frenzy and there was no time to wallow.

I had a pile of projects to get through and I wasn't going to let one paper stencil deter me...especially when I had such an awesome thrift find waiting to be transformed. Check this beauty out.

Blue Thrift Store Tray

One day a few weeks ago, I stopped at the thrift store not expecting to find much. They recently changed their pricing structure and as if it weren't bad enough before, now the prices are truly out of hand.

But there were dishes at home and laundry to be done, and shopping, even window shopping, sounded like a lot more fun.

Surprisingly, I found a few treasures, this teal tray being the most exciting one.

It was clearly handmade by someone, very sturdy, distressed and unbelievably, it was only four dollars. Four. Is that crazy or what? I guess homemade doesn't warrant a big price tag.

Bargain Price Thrift Store Tray Makeover

Lucky me, they had no idea what they had.

I spent the car ride home dreaming up ways to transform it. While it was in perfect condition, blue is just not my color. It needed paint. Something neutral I thought.

I've been working on lightening the place up a little and a cream or white would go well with my new decor.

There really wasn't any prep required, I went over it with a damp rag to clean away any dust or debris that might get caught in my brush and removed the handles with my super handy six in one screwdriver.

Removing Phillips Head Screws

It's literally the only tool that I have ever purchased for myself and I use it all the time since it has so many different flat and Phillips heads hidden inside. This one is new, because my wonderful husband keeps walking off with them as fast as I can buy them.

Six In One Screwdriver

I usually grab mine at Home Depot, but they're available everywhere.

Then I opened up my craft cabinet and grabbed my acrylic paint in a creamy white and applied it with a stiff bristle brush. That was the first coat.

Painting An Old Tray

Once it was dry, I applied a second coat with a foam brush so there wouldn't be any bristle marks or lines in the paint. I wanted a smooth finish. There were a few spots that required a third coat, but overall two did the trick.

How To Paint A Tray

While it was drying, I began to think about my design. I contemplated adding feet to the tray, like I'd done to a few old cutting boards, but then vetoed the idea. I already had a board in mind that I wanted to turn into a standing tray.

It was the top of a toolbox my husband recently purchased, a giant slab that was just calling out to be transformed. Can you imagine how pretty this would be all dolled up?

Craftsman Tool Box Wood Top

Well, two of those trays would be overkill in this tiny cottage, so I decided to leave the tray in its current form and move on to the design.

That also gave me pause. It's such a pretty piece that I wanted to be able to use it all year round. When I bought the tray I was thinking about using those paper stencils to make it a fall decor item, but after the apple cutting board mess, I decided against that.

Never again, thank you very much.

That's when my daughter breezed through the kitchen and suggested that I use the garland stencil I was originally going to use on the apple. She told me that she thought it would look cool if it I painted it on in another shade of white, a tone on tone accent that would be appropriate in any season.

How To Stencil On Wood

How perfect. The girl's a genius. I loved that idea, so that's exactly what I did. And this time it worked out very well.

The plastic stencil didn't budge, bleed or fray and she was right, the subtly of the design was just enough to add an elegant flair to the rustic tray, but not overwhelm it.

Stenciled Thrift Store Tray

Now, I can use it all year long, winter, spring, summer...

Summer Tea Time

...and even fall. All I have to do it change up what I place on it and I've got a charming decoration or a functional serving piece. Or both.

One of these days, I'll have my husband take it outside and spray it with a matte sealer to protect the paint.

Fall Tray Decor

In the meantime, it looks fabulous in my kitchen.

And I'm not a DIY stenciling failure anymore.

Redemption and a new accessory to play with.

Not bad for four bucks.

Have you had any crafty do over lately?


  1. Hi Kim,
    You transformed that beautifully. Love the color and the stenciling. Beautiful job with your crafty self!
    Happy New Week.

  2. Love it! The perfect finish for a great piece! And YES-you are redeemed! xo Diana

  3. I love the tray and you painted it such a pretty white and I love the stencil you chose. It's beautiful and I know you'll enjoy using it! :)

  4. Fabulous, Kim! I love the white on white and the contrast of the black handles against the white. Love, too, how you dressed it up with your pretties. Congratulations on a win! Hugs, Nancy

  5. LOOKS GREAT, but I would be so tempted to go after it with some sandpaper and let a bit of that color show through...but then I seldom work on anything that isn't at least 100 years old and many layers of colors. Perfect idea though!

  6. You did good! I really like how it turned out. I would never have thought of doing white and white, but what a great idea.

  7. Your daughter is a chip off the block! Her idea and your amazing stencil skills rocked this project! It truly is a beautiful tray makeover.

  8. White on White and convenient for any season. Good find, good upcycle.

  9. Hi Kim, love this tray and the tonal look. Makes a pretty statement. $4 for the piece was great, looks sturdy.

    Sorry haven't been here of late. Had a head cold that was from the devil

    Have a great day


  10. That garland stencil is perfect! I love that it is neutral and you can change it up for any season.

  11. It turned out wonderful and such a great useful piece!

  12. I love it Kim, the wreath is perfect <3

  13. I would of walked right that tray. Potential? I couldn't see it. If I did buy it, I would of kept the color. Not that it would go with anything...just saying.

  14. Goood work, Kim! Of course. Nice that your daughter has interited some of your genes. And isn't it great when yoh can simply go to your stash and find thed supplies you need? Makes crafting easier.

  15. Well I say, could you mail that beautiful tray to me. ;-) LOVE IT! What a find.
    Well done, as always!

  16. What a beautiful tray! I like the stencil design you chose and the tone on tone looks wonderful.

  17. The transformation is remarkable! Love that you painted it white! Gorgeous!


Hey~ before you go, let me know what you think! I love comments and respond to them all. Thanks so much for visiting! *Please refer to our privacy policy if you have questions regarding your profile.

Get The Newsletter! Sign Up