Are you a thrifter? Grab my free tips! Click Here!

Vintage Wooden Candle Holder Makeover

March 10, 2023

This post may contain affiliate links.

Sometimes the ugliest thrift store finds can make the most beautiful DIYs.

My wooden candle holder makeover turned a burnt, waxy mess into a stunning piece of decor. 

Damaged Wooden Candle Holder Burnt and Covered In Wax

Over the past several years thrift store shopping has become one of my very favorite pastimes.

I used to enjoy popping into one occasionally. On my way to a Marshalls or HomeGoods.

However, over the past two years, I've completely abandoned the chain stores and find myself browsing the thrift aisles on a regular basis instead.

Why?

Well, for one thing they're all in different towns, so they all have very different types of merchandise. 

They also get new items daily, so you never know what you're going to find and, best of all, since they're second hand shops, everything is cheap.

And let's face it, that's the best part.

You see, then I can shop to my heart's content and not spend more than a few bucks for a big thrill.

A new decor accessory.

Frog Pitcher and Animal Figurines on thrift store shelves

Or a crafty DIY challenge.

My favorite.

Sometimes, the challenge seems so great, it's almost like I'm daring myself to see if I can make some true treasure out my...well, not trash...but...sometimes, yes. Trash.

That's exactly what happened when I found today's makeover.

Granted, it was in really, really bad shape. Truly terrible shape, but unique enough to pique my interest.

In perfect condition, they go for about $46.00. Mine was two bucks, which was still too much in my opinion. In fact, I walked by it several times.

But in the end, its siren song was too powerful to resist.

A Very Ugly Candlestick Makeover Pinterest Pin

When I brought it home, I realized how severely it was damaged. Wax had spilled all over the wood. The cups were filled with it and worst of all, the top of two or three of the cups were badly burned.

Charred. And they left a black, chalky dust on my hands every time I touched one.

Oh boy. I honestly wondered if I'd made a mistake, but I decided to give it the old Exquisitely Unremarkable try.

My Wooden Candle Holder Makeover

Now I know mine is very unique, but I hope you can use this idea if you find or have an old wooden candle holder that's in need of little love.

Supplies:

Step 1. Freeze It


I started by placing the entire icky holder in two ziploc bags and placed it on a towel in my freezer.

Wooden candle holder in plastic ziplock bags on a table

I didn't want it anywhere near my food. It was that gross. 

I put it in the freezer for several hours to chill...(candle holder in the freezer)

Step 2: Remove The Wax


Several hours later, when it was super cold, I took it out and used my nail to flake the frozen wax off. 

It was a simple job and when I was done, I had enough wax to make my own candle.

Using a fingernail to remove frozen wax from wood

I did have to use a screwdriver to pop the old wax out of the candle cups.

There was just too much of it for the nail trick.

Scooping Old Wax Out Of Candle Cup with a screwdriver

Next, I used a small sandpaper sponge to remove any of the wax that was super stuck and to smooth out the charred wood.

Sanding Wooden Candle Holder

Step 3: Clean It


Then I wiped the entire piece down with a little vinegar/water solution and a dry paper towel.

Washing Off Candle Holder with paper towel
Looking better already! Well, if you ignore the fire damage. 😉

Step 4: Paint It


Now originally, I had planned on using Rub N Buff to cover the wood. Clearly, it was in no shape to be refinished and I had no intention of rebuilding the charred cups with putty or wood filler. 

That meant covering the wood with color was my next best option. But.

I'd never used Rub N Buff before and once I opened it and smelled it...nope. It was too stinky for my tricky lungs. It also looked like a lot of work to cover all those intricate spindle details.

Instead, I opted for spray paint. Tried and true.

(And my husband does the painting!)

Rustoleum Pure Gold Paint and Primer in One

It worked well, but the color was a little cold. It looked nothing like the can.

I've become a real brass candlestick junkie lately, so my intention was to turn this wooden charmer into a show stopping centerpiece to match my collection. 

The tone just wasn't warm enough to coordinate. 

That's when I grabbed gloves, a mask and my coat, and sat outside and gave the base a quick coat of the Rub N Buff after all.

Rub N Buff On Wooden Candlestick

Unfortunately, it didn't do the trick either.

In a last ditch effort, I grabbed a jar of brown antiquing gel and coated the entire piece with it. That did the trick.

Using Antiquing Gel On Wooden Candlestick- Antiquing Gel To The Rescue

Step 5: Add Floral Rings


My last issue was those burned cups.

The charred areas were now gold, but the cups were still misshapen. They didn't look terrible, but they weren't really good looking either.

That's when I decided to make two quick floral beaded candle rings to cover them up. Plus they added a bit of interest.

Beaded Flower Candle Ring on white taper candle

In the end, my ugly duckling of a candle holder turned out to be a gorgeous, elegant, dare I say show stopping, new addition to my brass candlestick collection.

Thrift Store Wooden Multi Taper Wooden Candle Stick Holder Makeover

With real candles.

Brass Multi Candlestick Holder under a plate rack on a pine buffet

Or better yet, my favorite battery operated timer tapers, since I don't think this poor baby could endure another round of fire damage.

Either way, it looks outstanding.

Wooden Candle Holder Spray painted gold and displayed with candles lit

So much so that I can't believe I hesitated to grab it.

Silly girl.

😉

I hope this inspires you to take think twice the next time something closer to trash than treasure catches your eye at a sale.

I also hope you'll stick around and check out all the links below for today's Thrifty Style Team hop hosted by Julie from Redhead Can Decorate

Mine is not the only shocking transformation being shared today.

Look at all these befores...you know you want to see the afters!

Shocking Thrift Store Makeovers Graphic with 10 before photos

Let the hopping begin!!

Redhead Can Decorate - How to Create a Thrift Store Basket Wall Corner
Our Crafty Mom - How to Make a Vintage Tea Cup Planter
I Should Be Mopping the Floor - Cheese Dome Turned Seasonal Cloche
The How to Home - 10 Ideas for Decorating with Thrift Store Antique Bakeware
DIY Beautify- Easy Flowers From Mason Jar Lids
Songbird -  Thrift Store Bunnies Makeover
Simple Nature Decor - Beautiful Decoupage Wall Art
Zucchini Sisters - Thrift Store Ceramic Cherub Makeover
Exquisitely Unremarkable - That's me! 
A Life Unfolding -  Ten Thrifting Tips and Tricks

Happy Thrifting Friends!!
Kim Signature


Post a Comment | 58 Comments

Hey~ before you go, let me know what you think!

I love comments and respond to them all.

*Please refer to our privacy policy if you have questions regarding your profile and note that comments with links will not be published.



  1. Wow, this looks fantastic! Send some goof thrifting our way.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Cindy! I had a feeling this one had great potential…and for two bucks I was willing to take the risk!
      Happy weekend!

      Delete
  2. Now that’s waxing poetic!
    Thought you might need an intervention till you said battery candles. Love the rings, too. Awesome vision!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Haha...yes, battery candles for sure. That poor little candle holder had literally been through the fire and once is enough for sure! And thanks so much, this was a fun one!

      Delete
  3. That turned out great. I think that is a talent to be able to spot the potential in something most people would pass by. Love it and it's a beauty now. Well worth the effort.
    Off on a trip with 3 of my girls and I am driving on snow covered roads--3 hours I think. UGH...It's still snowing and ugly. xo Diana

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Diana! I'm not sure if it's a talent, but for me, at least, it's fun. I like the challenge and the process of dreaming about what it could be...I hope you have / had a safe trip. The weather has been wicked in your neck of the woods this winter. Maybe the later sunset will scare the snow away for good!! xo

      Delete
  4. You did it again! It looks so good!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Deanna!! I really do enjoy the process and the challenge.

      Delete
  5. Wow! Kim, you did a great job with this makeover. I love how the candle holder looks spray painted gold with those pretty candles. Enjoy!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Julie! Thank goodness for spray paint…and a husband who is willing to do it for me. Hahaha!!

      Delete
  6. Wow, another great find and thank you for the tutorial. I was able to go thrifting with my sister when visiting her. I found several fun finds.
    I agree, visiting thrift stores in different areas is fun too. Eagle River is a tourist town. The thrift shops are full of a lot of cabin stuff.
    Carla

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Carla, and thrifting with your sister sounds like fun, especially in another town. I love the local flair of shops like that and the rustic cabin stuff sounds cool. We don't have a lot of that here and I like it!!

      Delete
  7. Love the battery operated candles great idea. The gold looks so pretty. Great re love. Hugs. Kris

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Kris! It was in such bad shape I almost couldn't believe the thrift shop didn't throw it away...I guess that was my good fortune. Hugs to you and have a great week!

      Delete
  8. You have a much better eye than me! I saw that and wondered what you could do to make it look better! And you did it! The little flower rings add so much to it as well. Nice job! And now I'm off to visit some of the others.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Mari! Funny thing, I bought that little garland to make candle rings for spring on my other tapers, so I had it on hand. I guess it was meant to be!

      Delete
  9. Well that most definitely qualifies as a shockingly good makeover, Kim. 10/10. You'd never guess it was the same sad candle holder.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Shockingly good....ooh...Michelle, what fun words! Thank you!!

      Delete
  10. This looks soooo pretty! Wasn't sure you were going to pull it off for a second! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you!! Yes, you and me both..especially once I got it home and saw how badly the cups were damaged, but there's not a lot spray paint can't fix! Thankfully!

      Delete
  11. Kim,
    I love using that paint and have done so more times then i care to mention as I am a Gold lover..It looks fantastic!! and may I say that it is Exquisitely REMARKABLE!!! Thanks for sharing and thanks so much for stopping by and for your sweet words my friend!!!! Being up on a hill with 13 steps to walk up to get to our row of townhouses does have the advantage of beautiful views....From my bedroom windows, I can see clear across the valley over to the mountains on the other side of the Susquehanna River....I hope you have a great weekend!!
    Hugs,
    Deb

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Deb! I do love paint, I think it really is the base of 99% of my makeovers. And you do live in a magical place. The views are truly outstanding, it's like a resort!!

      Delete
  12. What a great makeover! I am so glad that you didn't pass it up. It looks so beautiful now. xo

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks so much, Mary Beth! I have to say the shape of this one was intriguing and it was worth a $2 risk...even if it was totally disgusting! 🤣

      Delete
  13. Oh my goodness!!! Kim this is so beautiful!!! This would cost a fortune if it was real brass and you made it look legit real! Nice work!!! -Julie redheadcandecorate.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Julie and thanks for hosting such a fun hop...I love thinking outside the box and your hop challenges me to do so!

      Delete
  14. Wow what a beautiful transformation this candle holder got! You really did such a great job with this and are so inspiring!

    -Rachel
    raeelizabethdesign.com

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Rachel, you just made my day with your sweet comment. Thank you!

      Delete
  15. This turned out so good Kim! I think layering paint and glazes always adds nice depth and your beauty looks like real brass!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree, Cindy. I'm not usually patient enough to layer, but it was so worth it. I may have to do it more often...and thanks!

      Delete
  16. Holy moly, what a makeover! For you to even see potential in that gross candle holder is amazing. And what fortitude you have, especially with the wax. I have no patience! Your end result is beautiful.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Melanie, it was gross. I didn’t even want to put it in the freezer, that’s why it was wrapped up like it was wearing a hazmat suit! 🤣Honestly, the wax removal took less than 5 minutes and it was kind of fun…the painting and buffing and gel coating was what got me, but in the end it was worth it. Thanks for stopping by!!

      Delete
  17. I am in love with this candle stick makeover and I love the process you did to take off the wax. Thanks so much for that tip.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My pleasure! I'm always happy to share in the hopes it inspires others to give it a try. 😊

      Delete
  18. I am in love with the candleholder makeover. The process to take off the wax is a great tip.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Maria! I've used the freezer method on small wax spills, but I wasn't sure if it was going to do the trick this time. Thankfully, it did!

      Delete
  19. Honestly, when I saw the first picture, I thought: "How in the world is she going to pull this off??" But you DID it! This candle holder turned out amazing! It IS show-stopping and elegant, and fits in perfectly with your metal candle holders. And adding the candle rings was genius: you hid those messed up cups in plain sight! Beautifully done!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Kristine! I have to say I love the way it turned out, but when I left the shop I had no idea what I was going to do with it. Glad you like it!

      Delete
  20. Wonderful project. You saw the potential and now it is lovely. The battery candles are awesome.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Linda! I really do enjoy a challenge. I like to learn new skills, too and give my brain a stretch. I hope you have a lovely week!

      Delete
  21. Kim-- wow! What a makeover. You did wonders for this candle holder for sure. Love that you spotted this gem and had an inkling of its potential! xoxo, kristi

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Kristi! I think that's what I love most about thrifting...you never know what you're going to find! xoxo

      Delete
  22. Very nice, and I like the floral rings for spring!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank Ricki Jill! I had fun with this one...and yes, those floral rings are my desperate attempt to lure spring. Unfortunately, it's not working, we're expecting snow tomorrow. Boo! Hope you have sunshine!

      Delete
  23. That is quite a transformation, Kim. It's always amazing what a little elbow grease and some paint can do. Great makeover!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Ann! Yes, paint to the rescue. Again!! Also, honestly, once it came out of the freezer , the wax just popped right off. I love that.

      Delete
  24. Wow! Great transformation! And it only cost $2!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks so much...and yup, it was definitely a bargain!

      Delete
  25. Imgc this diy is a-mazing. I love everything you did, you truly took an ugly Duckling and turned it into a beautiful swan 🦢. I love the idea of using batteries operated batteries. I was wondering how to avoid the same thing happening to your fabulous creation, then you show us. Thank you so much

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks so much, Ivory! I agree, those candles are my favorites. I haven't lit a match around here in years. I think that candle holder is breathing a quiet sigh of relief!! Hahaha! I really appreciate the comment and hope you'll pop in again soon!

      Delete
  26. How did I not know about the freezer trick. I can't believe how beautiful it is now. Once again you worked your magic. xo Laura

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My mom taught me about the freezer trick when I was a little girl. It’s come in quite handy over the years…but never more than now!

      Delete
  27. Kim, this looks just fabulous! I love the finish and your tutorial is so helpful. Thanks for the inspiration. Happy Spring!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Michelle! I had fun with this makeover. I hope it inspires others to try something similar.

      Delete
  28. That freezer trick is the best. We have so many wax encrusted things that need a good clean, but the thought of breaking my nails always puts me off, so we just ignore them and add fresh wax :D Love how you made a plan to hide the chip, too plus the paint job changes the look completely. They're so classy and elegant now.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This one needed a lot of help for sure, but that freezer did all the heavy lifting. No broken nails!! After that, it was a simple process that I hope will give others the confidence to try.

      Delete
  29. Kim, you really worked your magic this time -it's beautiful!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks so much! I second guessed myself once I got it home, but after I pulled it out of the freezer it was smooth sailing! Of course, then I needed to clean my freezer!! Ha!!

      Delete